Guest Stars Jody Hill as Levi J. LaRose as Gregory Troy Hogan as Matthew James DuMont as Chad Kristen Johnston as May-May Montgomery Steve Zahn as Peter Montgomery Lukas Haas as Chuck Montgomery Robert Oberst as Karl Montgomery Stephen Schneider as Stephen Stephen Louis Grush as Jacob Quincy Dunn-Baker as Dakota Sturgill Simpson as Marshall Casey Wilson as Kristy Co Starring Xander Mateo Delatorre as Brody Kora Kokavec as Poppy Mike Ortiz as Militia Member Aaron Goldenberg as Percy David Alexander as Pastor Isaiah