Guest Stars Sam Ashby as Jackson Lewis Harlan Drum as CeCe Matney Hunter Burke as Trotter Vidhyarkorn Tracey Bonner as Pastor June Wilkes Brittany L. Smith as Peggy Martin Al-Jaleel Knox as Gabe Weatherspoon Caroline Lagerfelt as Paula Vreeland Frank Oakley III as Harlan Bixby Michael Shenefelt as Ryan Wingate Luray Cooper as Skeeter Ramsey Wynn Everett as Kathy Gabriella Garcia as Sophie Frazier Lana Jean Turner as Willow William Mark McCullough as Russ Matney Leander Suleiman as Dr. Manal Ahmed Zele Avradopoulos as Principal Puckett K.D. O'Hair as Tessa Matney Tony Kramer as Emil Anna Oakley as Mom