Guest Stars Tovah Feldshuh as Bat Lady Antonio Cipriano as Buck Renna Didi Conn as Martha Friedman Samantha Bugliaro as Ashley Kent Kristoffer Polaha as Brad Bolitar Narci Regina as Kitty Bolitar Geoffrey Cantor as Mr. V. Co Starring Lee Aaron Rosen as Chief Ken Taylor Hunter Emery as Sunglasses Man Luke Marinkovich as Paramedic / Luther Maximo Masefield as Young Brad Dustin Charles as Arthur Spindell, Sr. Sadie Veach as Young Shira Jen Jacob as Mrs. Kent Kamron Ali Toosi as Ricky Daniel Adaro as Young Luther Zander Pacella as Teen Ken Kate Edmonds as Teen Hannah Micah Polaha as Teen Brad Erika Longo as Cop #1 Sung Yoon as Player 2 Benjamin McGowan as Upperclassman 2 Alestair Shu as Alec David Manuele as Player 1 Brian Beckerle as Upperclassman 1 Ben Graney as Bob James Ward as Principal Gorelick