Guest Stars Kaitlyn Black as Annabeth Nass Mircea Monroe as Tansy Truitt Laura Bell Bundy as Shelby Sinclair Charlie Robinson as Sergeant Jeffries Golden Brooks as Ruby Jeffries Travis Van Winkle as Jonah Breeland Charlotte Newhouse as Contestant Co Starring John Eric Bentley as Sheriff Bill John Marshall Jones as Wally Maynard Alan Autry as Todd Gainey Sr. Raymond Lee as Andrew Devon Ogden as Sorority Girl Dillan Arrick as College Girl Kristy Johnson as Kitty Lyons