Guest Stars Trieste Kelly Dunn as Siobhan Kelly Ana Ayora as Nina Cruz Casey Labow as Maggie Bunker Eliza Dushku as Veronica Dawson Erik King as Dr. Tim Hubbard Frederick Weller as Declan Bode Robert Sedgwick as Hightower Chance Kelly as Randall Watts Co Starring Steve Coulter as Elijah Bowman Samantha Worthen as Miriam Bowman Cathy O'Dell as Helen Vicks Corey Rieger as Pony Joe Robert Oppel as Dom Tiffany Williams as Gail Westcott Bennett Vesprini as Tocho Jesse Harrison as Amish Man Lauren Mae Shafer as Tammy Francis John Shepard as Felix Nancy Wetzel as Amish Woman