Guest Stars Louanne Stephens as Ruby Graham Greene as Malachi Strand Bex Taylor-Klaus as Vivian Lee Garlington as Ruth Tara Buck as Phoebe Greene Troy Ruptash as Lanny Greene Chris Freihofer as Alan Little Charlotte Alexis White as Sofia Myk Watford as Norwood Young Mary Elise Hayden as Polina Yazov Co Starring Brian Houtz as Gareth Ashbery Nate Warren as Younger Man