Guest Stars Emma Caulfield as Anya Jenkins Kristine Sutherland as Joyce Summers Alexis Denisof as Wesley Wyndham-Pryce Brad Caleb Kane as Tucker Wells Co Starring Danny Strong as Jonathan Levinson Bonita Friedericy as Mrs. Finkle Joe Howard as Priest Michael Zlabinger as Student at Mic Mike Kimmel as Harv Tove Kingsbury as Tux Boy Monica Serene Garnich as Pretty Girl Damien Eckhardt as Jack Mayhew Stephanie Denise Griffin as Tux Girl Andrea Baker as Sales Girl