Guest Stars Kristin Dattilo as Harriett 'Harry' Doyle Carlos Jacott as Richard Howard Straley Co Starring Lauri Johnson as Aunt Martha Chris Tallman as Nick Straley Rib Hillis as Pierce Ted Kairys as Ben Straley Brad Blaisdell as Uncle John Kristen Lowman as Rachel Straley David Polcyn as Russ Uncredited Sarah Michelle Gellar as Buffy Anne Summers