Guest Stars D.B. Sweeney as US Marshal Cynthia Watros as Heather Vanderwaal William Sadler as Ray Finnegan Leith Burke as Jerry Sorum Lawrence Pressman as Judge Schuller Vincent Guastaferro as Det. Gil Hardesty Cliff Weissman as Drew Sandweiss Co Starring Cade Owens as Jack Hotchner Dale Waddington Horowitz as Medical Examiner Glenn Keogh as Sean Hannah Brylowe as Allison Sandweiss