Guest Stars Jerry Adler as Howard Lyman Chris Butler as Matan Brody Margo Martindale as Ruth Eastman Felix Solis as Detective Kevin Rodriguez Christopher McDonald as Judge Don Schakowsky Nikki M. James as Monica Timmons Vanessa Williams as Courtney Paige Peter Gallagher as Ethan Carver Brian Muller as Brian Carter Phillip Shinn as Dirk Don Stark as Manny Hofstedter Josh Stamberg as Dr. Joseph Portnow Michelle Duffy as Patricia Evra Lauren Molina as Lucy Van Gaal Co Starring José Ramón Rosario as Harris the Sheriff Victoria Vazquez as Foreperson