Guest Stars Emmy Clarke as Julie Teeger Drew Matthews as Third Orphan Dan Hedaya as Jack Monk Catherine Bach as Sara Jo Brian Kerwin as Ben Glaser Christie Lynn Smith as Valerie Joe Holt as Midland Detective Deborah Geffner as Nun Larry Udy as Bo Alex Morris as Red Tom Everett as Kenneth Woods Matt Eyde as Prison Guard Jenna Seitz as Choking Orphan Rachel Rogers as First Orphan Sara De Berry as Fourth Orphan Co Starring Bryce Robinson as Excited Orphan