Guest Stars Kelsey Batelaan as Annie McNamara Jessalyn Gilsig as Gina Russo Brittany Snow as Ariel Alderman Rhona Mitra as Kit McGraw Willam as Cherry Peck Brian Kerwin as Eugene Alderman Veronica Cartwright as Mother Mary Claire Alejandra Gutierrez as Spanish Woman Colleen Flynn as Julia's Doctor Suzanne Longo as Carver Victim