Guest Stars Vincent Guastaferro as Desk Sgt. Vincent Agostini Ruben Santiago-Hudson as Otis Raymond Cruz as Raoul Jasmine Guy as LaVonna Runnels Barry Shabaka Henley as Roger Billings Jeremiah Birkett as Ricky Winston K. Todd Freeman as Arthur Cartwell Samaria Graham as Denise Ludlow Beatrice Winde as Gladys Denton Samantha MacLachlan as Chantal LaTanya Richardson as Sister Cecilia Co Starring James Luca McBride as Officer Mike Shannon Joe Santos, Jr. as Officer Joey Aiello Barbara Allyne-Bennet as Saleswoman Leigh Kim as Technologist Deanna Shapiro as Cosmetologist Rob Giannetta as Waterfront Cop Mark Schulte as White Guy Rocael Rueda Jr. as El Salvadorian Man