Guest Stars Meredith Eaton as Bethany Horowitz Michael Ensign as Judge Paul Resnick William Russ as Assistant D.A. Christopher Palmer Debra Mooney as Judge Patrice Webb Patrick Renna as Warren Peters, Attorney Michael Patrick McGill as Detective Brian Whistler Megan Mullally as Renata Hill Jake Richardson as Witness Graham Judith Moreland as Detective Ellen Adams Lovensky Jean-Baptiste as Jerome Harris Pete Gardner as Mr. Nayman