Guest Stars Ben Shenkman as Curtis Gates Debra Monk as Deniece Parsons Lily Tomlin as Marilyn Tobin Ebon Moss-Bachrach as Nick Salenger Dominic Chianese as Stuart Zedeck Co Starring Michael Pemberton as Malcolm Jennifer Roszell as Deb Shayes Vanessa Ray as Tessa Marchetti Paul Carafotes as Man in Overcoat Tara Summers as Alex Benjamin Miriam Shor as Carrie Parsons Peter Jay Fernandez as Judge J.T. Reilly Bill Raymond as Albert Wiggins J. Tucker Smith as Rick Renfro Ewa Da Cruz as Prostitute Erin Quill as Female Victim #2 Novella Nelson as Older Female Victim Marina Squerciati as Young Anne Connel Charlie Semine as Boyfriend Tim Miller as Male Board Member #2 Todd Davis as Detective Petronia Paley as Female Board Member #1