Guest Stars Jon Gries as Broots James Denton as Mr. Lyle Leigh Taylor-Young as Michelle Lucca Stamatis Darren Kennedy as Nicholas "Nick" Stamatis Andrew J. Robinson as Lieutenant Jenkins Kirsten Nelson as ATF Agent Beth Swik Jacqueline Piñol as Kidnapped Teacher Scott Atkinson as ATF Agent Martin Joe Unger as Eldridge Hailey Dakota Leopardi as Seth Co Starring Willie Gault as Willie the Sweeper Emmett Miller as TV News Anchor Cedric Harris as Staffer