Guest Stars Aya Sumika as Special Agent Liz Warner Michelle Nolden as AUSA Robin Brooks Bill Nye as Professor Bill Waldie Sharif Atkins as Clay Porter Mireille Enos as Grace Ferraro Derek Phillips as Ryan Ferraro Laivan Greene as Jenna Porter Co Starring Kenneth Dolin as Brother Theo Jack Guzman as Carlos Ruiz Zack Duhame as James Pinkney Ryan Carr as Checkout Guy Uncredited Yaani King Mondschein as Laurie Porter Richard Lawson as Clay Porter, Sr.