Guest Stars Alan Cumming as Eli Gold Zach Grenier as David Lee Sonequa Martin-Green as Courtney Wells James Carpinello as Detective Anthony Burton Peter Gerety as Judge Timothy Stanek Paige Turco as Caroline Wilder Holley Fain as Shaina Whitmore Michael Laurence as Max Wilder Brian Reddy as Dr. Boyd Bryce Pinkham as Dr. Hanson Justin Hagan as Jay Van Zandt Mark Blum as Julius Kreutzer Co Starring Tess Paras as Lisa Doreen Montalvo as Nurse