Guest Stars Zach Grenier as David Lee Mike Colter as Lemond Bishop Titus Welliver as Glenn Childs Scott Porter as Blake Calamar Renée Elise Goldsberry as Geneva Pine Mike Pniewski as Frank Landau Gbenga Akinnagbe as Pastor Isaiah Easton Rachel Hilson as Nisa Dalmar Eric Ruffin as Dylan Bishop J.D. Williams as Dexter Roja Ismael Cruz Córdova as Jimmy Patrick Jerry Strong as Matt Becker Pablo Schreiber as Gregory Mars Bill Irwin as Fred Medkiff Sophina Brown as Katrina Bishop Paul Urcioli as Hemings