Guest Stars Michael Cerveris as James Castro John Ventimiglia as Detective Gary Prima Christian Borle as Carter Schmidt John Procaccino as Judge Thomas Glatt Taye Diggs as Dean Levine-Wilkins Linda Lavin as Joy Grubick Tibor Feldman as Judge Ilya Petrov Robert Sean Leonard as Del Paul Richard Thomas as Ed Pratt Brandon J. Dirden as Joss Acker Robert Joy as Wendell Keller Andrew Polk as Derek Voss Co Starring Nicole Roderick as Nora Danielle Ferland as Martha Toms Saycon Sengbloh as Stacie Wagner Gloria Steinem as Herself Frank Seddio as Himself