Guest Stars April Parker-Jones as Darcy Hawkins Bob Stephenson as Jimmy Taylor Richard Speight, Jr. as Bill Kohler Candace Bailey as Skylar Stevens Sterling Ardrey as Samuel Hawkins Jazz Raycole as Allison Hawkins Siena Goines as Sarah Mason Daniel Benzali as Thomas Valente Christopher Wiehl as Roger Hammond Ron Bottitta as The Hunter Dan Sachoff as Harry Carmichael Jeffrey Vincent Parise as Kyle Erica Tazel as Jessica Williams Adam Donshik as Victor Lewis Warren Sweeney as Mr. Simmons Ned Schmidtke as Reverend Frank Young Joshua Wheeler as Hank Ryan Tutton as The Brother Mia Ford as The Sister