Guest Stars Raúl Esparza as Rafael Barba Peter McRobbie as Judge Walter Bradley Nava Namdar as Jury Foreperson Elizabeth Marvel as Counselor Rita Calhoun Steve Rosen as Public Defender Guthrie Tonye Patano as Judge Linda Maskin Adam Baldwin as Captain Steven Harris Rory O'Malley as Craig Jane Dashow as Holly Roger Bart as Adam Cain Anna Chlumsky as Jocelyn Paley Romy Rosemont as Kathleen Dobson Hallie Cooper-Novack as Katie J. Elaine Marcos as Lisa Vaughn Lucia Spina as Sara Palermo Jay McInerney as Himself Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration