Special Guest Stars Aisha Tyler as Mia Dickerson Guest Stars David Berman as Dr. David Phillips Wallace Langham as David Hodges Marc Vann as Conrad Ecklie Larry Sullivan as Officer Akers Victoria Prescott as Judy Tremont José Zúñiga as Det. Chris Cavaliere James Patrick Stuart as Adam Matthews Jason Segel as Neil Jansen Tina Lifford as Judge Witherspoon Jason London as Keith Garbett Wil Wheaton as Walter Lee Tergesen as Martin Hawkins Cleo King as Lucy Stephen Baldwin as Jesse Acheson Erin Matthews as Martha Krell David Newsom as Hayden Michaels Tamara Clatterbuck as Michelle Acheson Andy Gobienko as Matt Hawkins Diane DiLascio as Yvonne Hawkins Co Starring Russell Sams as Front Desk Clerk