Guest Stars Fred Koehler as Wesley Lewis Kaylee Bryant as Amber Amy Stewart as Jennifer Lennox Brendan Meyer as Claudio Moretti Co Starring Maddie Phillips as Lacy Siddon Catherine Lough Haggquist as Detective Francis Dunne Valerie Tian as Bethany Cate Sproule as Harper Alison Wandzura as FBI Agent Cottler Donny Lucas as Eric Ashby Richard Keats as Spencer Morrow Leigh Bourque as Talia Lennox Marrett Green as News Reporter Shayn Solberg as Derrick Cotton Fiona Hogan as Principal Larsen