Guest Stars Jillian Fargey as Sophie Bascomb Juliana Wimbles as Lisa Herman Rebecca Toolan as Mrs. Helen Houser Ty Olsson as Sheriff Jim Grant Marion Eisman as Mrs. Linda Norton Garry Chalk as Mayor Bascomb Viv Leacock as Deputy George Peterson Lina Renna as Lucy Miller Jesse Moss as Kevin Miller Aaron Pearl as Gary Koehler Lauren K. Robek as Janet Venus Terzo as Nettie Grant Brenna O'Brien as Carly Winters Marilyn Norry as Edna Morse Hannah Pederson as Paige Miller Flora Karas as Clerk Nicholas Marinos as John Morse Matt Fentiman as Car Owner