Guest Stars Debra Mooney as Judge P. Spindle John Hawkes as Stuart Donovan Caroline Kava as Mary Donovan David Moreland as A.D.A. Matthew Platt Charles Durning as Stephen Donnell George D. Wallace as Judge Andrew Wood Robert Curtis Brown as Scott Simpson Wanda-Lee Evans as Mrs. Raymonds Lance E. Nichols as Evidence Room Officer Co Starring Cody Kasch as Scott Simpson, Jr. Faran Tahir as Dr. Michael Shields Dylan Kasch as Sammy Simpson Sara Van Horn as Aunt Laurie Sam Catlin as Kevin Houle Richard Voigts as Jury Foreman Jillian Crane as Linda Papp