Guest Stars Ray Abruzzo as Detective Michael McGuire Holland Taylor as Judge Roberta Kittleson Richard McGonagle as Judge Patrick Wilcox Teri Polo as Sarah Barker John L. Bader as Stanley Deeks Matthew Settle as Russell Bakey Sarah Rafferty as Judy Wilson Susan Floyd as A.D.A. Nancy Atkins Harry O'Reilly as Mark Wallace Co Starring James Burch as Randall Pyne Vance Knutsen as Chaplain Don Short as Jury Foreman