Guest Stars Tony Todd as Holyoke Dylan Neal as Keith Co Starring Morgan Taylor Campbell as Margot Ava Sleeth as 9 Year-Old Amy Jenna Berman as Krissy Glenn Ennis as Marvin Shaughnessy Redden as Amy's Dad Eliza Norbury as Amy's Mom Patrick Lubczyk as Kevin Hughes Devielle Johnson as Police Officer Lia Frankland as Francie Connor Mackay as Fireman