Guest Stars Zazie Beetz as Noelle Aya Cash as Sherri Dave Franco as Jeff Evan Jonigkeit as Matt Hannibal Buress as Jason Co Starring Noah Hopkins as Russ Jesse Diaz as Himself Michael David Hammond as New City Reporter #6 Margaret Bodnovich as Bartender Toni Nealie as New City Reporter #8 Todd Hieggelke as New City Reporter #7 Elliot Reichert as New City Reporter #5 Sarah Conway as New City Reporter #4 Ray Pride as New City Reporter #3 Robert Rodi as New City Reporter #2 Benjamin Schulman as New City Reporter #1 Justin Benzel as New City Photographer Randolph Baldwin as Cashier Lee McComb as Half Acre Brewer Megan McCloskey as Half Acre Tap Room Manager Brian Hieggelke as New City Editor Arthur Agee as Himself Andy Weil as Growler Guy Allison Latta as Sylvia (Realtor)