Guest Stars Ethan Sandler as ADA Jeffrey Brandau Tovah Feldshuh as Elaine Brandau Michelle Nolden as Dr. Amy Bowen Michael Welch as Josh Winter J.P. Manoux as Andrew Sorenson Christian Clemenson as Father Edward Klausner Larry Poindexter as Mr. O'Riley Douglas Smith as Steven Reynolds Co Starring Rob Swanson as Peterson Letitia Hannan as Isabel Haley