Guest Stars Daniel Stewart Sherman as Ennis Hart Michael Crane as John Wheeler Sasheer Zamata as Marcy Co Starring Darrin Baker as Robert John Fleming as Caleb Daveed Louza as Drunk Guy Philip Williams as Gerard Sr. Joan Massiah as Old Volunteer Susie McLean as Confessional Woman Karl Ang as Confessional Guy Terry Hart as Edgar Alec Stockwell as Steve Angela Gei as Suzie Cameryn Manning as Video Game Kid John Corbett as Husband