Recurring Guest Characters Wendy 1 guest appearances Eve 1 guest appearances Grace 1 guest appearances Craig 1 guest appearances Michael 1 guest appearances Peter 1 guest appearances Annie 1 guest appearances The Prankster 1 guest appearances Dave 1 guest appearances Tony 1 guest appearances Phil 1 guest appearances Black Boots 1 guest appearances 90s Kid 1 guest appearances Patience 1 guest appearances Katherine 1 guest appearances Diane 1 guest appearances Gina 1 guest appearances Cody's Mom 1 guest appearances Big Pilgrim 1 guest appearances Lady Pilgrim 1 guest appearances ⇤ « 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 » ⇥