Main Characters Captain Isaac Higgintoot 50 main appearances Samantha Arondekar 50 main appearances Jay Arondekar 50 main appearances Trevor Lefkowitz 50 main appearances Pete Martino 50 main appearances Alberta Haynes 50 main appearances Henrietta "Hetty" Woodstone 47 main appearances Sasappis 47 main appearances Thorfinn 47 main appearances Flower 40 main appearances
Recurring Guest Characters Sally 1 guest appearances Stage Manager 1 guest appearances Stagehand 1 guest appearances Mobster #1 1 guest appearances Mobster #2 1 guest appearances Delivery Man 1 guest appearances Alonzo 1 guest appearances Micah 1 guest appearances Alana 1 guest appearances Norm 1 guest appearances Dan 1 guest appearances Megan 1 guest appearances Lenape Bob 1 guest appearances Protestor 1 guest appearances Ulster Worker 1 guest appearances Lenape Villager 1 guest appearances Ted the Arborist 1 guest appearances Lenape Villager #2 1 guest appearances Randy 1 guest appearances Molly 1 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 » ⇥