Recurring Guest Characters Sharagim Kemp 2 guest appearances Colman Domingo 2 guest appearances Jensen Ackles 1 guest appearances Danneel Ackles 1 guest appearances Christian Serratos 1 guest appearances Sarah Wayne Callies 1 guest appearances Mark Duplass 1 guest appearances Katie Aselton 1 guest appearances Kelly Ripa 1 guest appearances Mark Consuelos 1 guest appearances Paul Rudd 1 guest appearances Julie Yaeger Rudd 1 guest appearances Jeannie Gaffigan 1 guest appearances Jim Gaffigan 1 guest appearances Rhea Seehorn 1 guest appearances Samantha Morton 1 guest appearances Patton Oswalt 1 guest appearances Meredith Salenger 1 guest appearances Michael Cudlitz 1 guest appearances Sophia Bush 1 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 » ⇥