Main Characters Pam Hupp 6 main appearances Leah Askey 6 main appearances Mariah Day 6 main appearances Mark Hupp 6 main appearances Russ Faria 6 main appearances Betsy Faria 5 main appearances Joel Schwartz 5 main appearances Janet 5 main appearances Detective Ryan McCarrick 4 main appearances
Recurring Guest Characters Lily Day 6 guest appearances Narrator 6 guest appearances Travis Hupp 5 guest appearances Nate Swanson 5 guest appearances Detective Michael Merkel 4 guest appearances Minnie 4 guest appearances Luci 4 guest appearances Cousin Mary 4 guest appearances Cathy Singer 4 guest appearances Tina 4 guest appearances Channel 2 Reporter 4 guest appearances Capt. Mike Lang 3 guest appearances Bonnie 3 guest appearances Mike Wood 3 guest appearances Jerry 2 guest appearances Sean Walker 2 guest appearances Jim 2 guest appearances Gus 2 guest appearances Evan 2 guest appearances Lisa 2 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 4 » ⇥