Guest Stars Susan Blommaert as Mr. Kaplan Lotte Verbeek as Young Katarina Rostova Charles Baker as Newton "Grey" Phillips William Sadler as Sam Milhoan Jack Topalian as Little Nikos Joanna P. Adler as Kathryn Nemec Amy Rutberg as Annie Kaplan Co Starring Bazzel Baz as Baz Lily Lewinter as Young Masha Bruce Faulk as Bobby J Spenser Granese as Jason Sean Brody as Man in Car Dave Stishan as Redneck Two Sabina Friedman-Seitz as Young Woman Jeremy Landon Hays as Father Madeleine Plener as Young Kate Ben Young III as Redneck One Karl Jacob as Ex-Con Curzon Dobell as Dr. Soska Lucia Spina as CSP Officer Olan Montgomery as Manager