Guest Stars Anna Chlumsky as Josie Trieste Kelly Dunn as Sonja Adam Kaufman as Tommy Shirley Rumierk as Paula Travato Co Starring Amy Schumer as Heather Brian O'Neill as Supervisor Ed Wheeler as Doorman Alexis Suarez as Doug Bryan Scott Johnson as Guard Faith Sandberg as Middle Aged Woman Joe Gonzalez as Uniformed Cop Craig Bockhorn as Middle Aged Detective Beth Adubato as News Anchor