Guest Stars Eric Nenninger as Scott Fiona Gubelmann as Lori Tony Plana as Berto Cedric Yarbrough as Jerry Co Starring Lisseth Chavez as Young Lydia Krys Marshall as Kristen Paul Karmiryan as Young Berto Lily Rains as Michelle Payam Banifaz as Tyler Jermaine Jacox as Hot UPS Guy Polina Frantsena as Abby Ryan Wilcox as Bar Patron