Guest Stars Rhyon Nicole Brown as Rebecca Van Exel Erika Alexander as Fran Winston Mitch Longley as Jonathan Ashworth Tom Welling as Rob Meltzer Julie Dretzin as Sarah Blixman Sandra Oh as Detective Shelly Tran Lanai Chapman as Winnie Van Exel J.D. Cullum as AAG Redfield Marla Gibbs as Zella Van Exel Cooper Thornton as 'Mr. Phil' Nevins Ryan James as Carl / Sasha Wilmer David Moreland as Lawyer Kirk Baily as Harry Winter Trie Donovan as Judy Kepler Ashlyn Morgan Williams as Samantha