Guest Stars Joel David Moore as Colin Fisher Sara Rue as Karen Delfs Marsha Thomason as Amy Bryan Jaleel White as Officer Adams Julie Claire as Psycho Sue Casey Alexie Gilmore as Cornelia Mills Mike Erwin as Matt Bogdan Rafi Gavron as Benny Pence Fred Cross as Gavin Mills Haley Tju as Meredith Hurley Guy Boyd as Philip Aubrey Justin Castor as Jacob Casey Co Starring Kalon Atkins as Andrew