Guest Stars Jessica Clement as Tina Funk Dylan Everett as Isaac Funk Joanne Miller as Justina Epp Cory Bowles as Jay Gates Lanette Ware as Chief Erica Kingsley Aaron Hale as Ben Novak Felix Bieger as Ezekiel Janzen Patrick Garrow as Gerry Epp Jordan Poole as Heinrich Epp Chris Bolton as Fred Voss Graham Bolton as Dirk Voss Allister Nathan MacDonald as Chad Nate White-Nogler as David Epp David Christoffel as Agent Clark Ava Peill as Greta Blatt Vikki Humphrey as Natalie Colin Hluchaniuk as Menno Worker