Guest Stars Richard Masur as Defense Attorney Bannon Cathryn Dylan as Abigail Chapman Chris Payne Gilbert as Professor Hall Anna Friedman as Bethany Pierson Sarah Denison as Mrs. Chapman Tim Decker as Mr. Malloy Penelope Walker as Judge Co Starring Brocki Murphy as Judge Tammy Windham Peter Defaria as Officer Tackett Madelyn Loehr as Kennedy Malloy Julie Dutchak as Clerk John Fenner Mays as Beefy Dude Sam Walt Jones as Eric Kyra Jones as Margo Tillerman Kevin Sciretta as Cristo Cera Naccarato as Stacy Boyd Karen Isabel Rodriguez as Natalie Jack Decesare as Brad Will Lidke as Todd Mitchell Dina Dicostanzo as Francis Harrison Alejandro Ortiz as Paul Sanchez
