Guest Stars Lauren Blumenfeld as Lucy Alexander Tara Karsian as Tanya Cassidy Freeman as Audrey Burris Romi Dias as Judge Irene Mendoza Annie Wersching as Bonnie Harris Michael Badalucco as Judge Jeff Mallard Erin Way as Faye Davies Cress Williams as ADA Gates David Fierro as Casper McTell Bruce Nozick as Dr. Stewart Tice Boise Holmes as FBI Agent Jeff Rawlings Co Starring Sewell Whitney as Juror #5 Ed Ackerman as Juror #1 Inger Tudor as Juror #3 Chiquita Fuller as Jury Foreman #2 Ari Herstand as Opponent Cinda Adams as Juror #4 Trevor Lee Georgeson as David Moss Andy Kim as Jury Foreman #1 Jason Lott as Daniel Sid Veda as Juror #2