Guest Stars Janel Moloney as Mary Jamison Wayne Duvall as Det. Louis Vitello Co Starring Marceline Hugot as Gladys Natalie Gold as Sam's Mother Dan Bittner as Craig MacNary Stephanie Kurtzuba as Sabrina Olga Sosnovska as Roxanna Noel Wilson as Mr. Johnson Peter Scanavino as Skinny Steven Randazzo as Angry Gambler Johnnie Mae as Nurse Tristan Farmer as Reverend Matt's Dad Michael Harrah as Doctor Mary Rasmussen as Reverend Matt's Mom Leslie Alexander as Casino Cashier Kyla Carter as Young Nora Chaka Desilva as Pit Boss Alan R. Rodriguez as Frank Mike Houston as Porter J. Paul Nicholas as The Orderly Jane Dashow as ER Nurse John Mainieri as Croupier Helmar Augustus Cooper as Jim Lewis Remy Bennett as Tina