Guest Stars James Kyson as Ando Masahashi Zachary Quinto as Sylar Ashley Crow as Sandra Bennet Jimmy Jean-Louis as The Haitian Elizabeth Lackey as Janice Parkman Matthew John Armstrong as Theodore Sprague Christopher Eccleston as Claude Rains Stana Katic as Hana Gitelman Missi Pyle as Hope Bill Fagerbakke as Steve Gustavson Rusty Schwimmer as Dale Smither Stan Lee as Bus Driver Christina Haag as Dr. Beth Lindall Co Starring Randall Bentley as Lyle Bennet Lilas Lane as Nathan's Aide