Guest Stars Carrie Aizley as Kitty Chadwick Ed Begley Jr. as Al Chadwick Amy Seimetz as Ally Keele Maria Blasucci as Julie Fenneman Matt Griesser as Rick Tillman Christopher Guest as Dave Chadwick Will Sasso as Accident Guy Mark Harelik as Tall Abe Lincoln Don Lake as Harvey Krupp Andrew Santino as Confederate Soldier Matt Braunger as Confederate Guard Ben Giroux as Short Abe Lincoln Scott Williamson as Phil Blukowsky Clint Lilley as Stunt Coordinator Darrell Rivers as Colonel Rivers