Guest Stars H. Jon Benjamin voices Jimmy Pesto Jr. John Roberts voices Jocelyn Sam Seder voices Hugo Habercore Ron Lynch voices Ron Jim Gaffigan voices Henry Haber Jon Daly voices Sasha Keegan-Michael Key voices Todd Rhys Darby voices Duncan Nick Kroll voices Mr. Desanto John Roberts voices Brenda Nick Kroll voices Customer Larry Murphy voices Moderator John Roberts voices Tameka