Guest Stars Caroline Kaplan as Rachel Grey Desmin Borges as Reed Kenworthy Meryl Jones Williams as Dr. Amy Levin James McCaffrey as Thornton Grey Arija Bareikis as Moira Dickerson Brendan Dooling as Troy Dickerson Michael Devine as David Co Starring Bobby Beckles as Bailiff Nicole Shalhoub as Prosecutor Valence Guy Whitlock as Judge Jason MacDonald as Clint Dickerson Dani Baum as Juror, #5 Tony Del Bono as Juror, #4