Guest Stars Peter Hermann as Grant Davidson Zak Orth as Roy McComb Donnie Keshawarz as Gerard David Lansbury as Matthew Ziegler Brian Tarantina as Nice Guy Co Starring Mira Tzur as Evelina Mendoza Megan Neuringer as Paula David Fonteno as Father Kent Chris Fischer as Uni Cop Clark Jackson as Young Pastor Peggy J. Scott as Mrs. Scott Kevin Isola as Technician Brandon Gill as Student Jasper McGruder as Control Room Tech Uncredited Michael Cerveris as September