Guest Stars Ari Graynor as Rachel Dunham Kiersten Warren as Sonia Francis David Pittu as Robert Swift Keith Nobbs as Carl Bussler Co Starring Lily Pilblad as Ella Blake Robyn Payne as NID FBI Agent Christopher Jackson as EMT Arjun Gupta as MIT Guy #1 Ana Berry as Newscaster Marnie Schulenburg as Mom Rafi Silver as Jonathan Swift Laura Perloe as Receptionist Kevin Rogers as Chris Hawkins Tim Gallin as Cameron Deglmann Jeremy Zorek as Tucker Robyn Rikoon as Lauren Chapman Craig Alan Edwards as Matt Uncredited Michael Cerveris as September